So, I follow biology. I don't study it but I find it very interesting to follow and read about.

So here's what I'm thinking. All life is cellular, but what if it didn't start that way? What if there was a working system of biomolecular condensates and reproductive nucleotide droplets in an environment that allowed for it to control the immediate surroundings it was in.

Now I think of life's origin as very likely to be geological, I have seen so many scientific discoveries that point to this, and chemistry is far different on geological timescales than it is in the reactive environments we create in labs and factories. So maybe a cavern inside the earth, maybe just a tiny pocket inside a rock, with no cell membranes or organelles, life could have slowly begun churning and being active, before vesicles and cell membranes were a factor.

I think this reduces the friction from problems like the absurd odds that everything would just suddenly come together to be a cell. Geology puts together simpler organic molecules that form biomolecular condensates, and what was probably a complex structure of RNA and amino acids, and the activity started. The activity could flow and find balance long before any vesicle becomes involved. It avoids the question of how did all the things needed find their way into the same vesicle in a timeframe that would allow cellular life as we know it to start before the process fizzles out.

It's not a theory, it's a hypothesis, and it's not from a researcher it's from someone sitting on the sidelines following research as it's published, but the more we discover about the origins of life, the more these thoughts are making sense to me lately.